The Ultimate Breakup Songs Quiz

Estimated Completion Time
4 min
The Ultimate Breakup Songs Quiz
Image: H. Armstrong Roberts/ClassicStock/Getty

About This Quiz

What becomes of the broken-hearted? Well, they usually wade back out into that big sea of fish, but not before wallowing in depressing — or occasionally empowering — breakup songs. Test your heartache with this quiz.
Let's start with a breakup song that has spawned loads of gossip. Who is "You're So Vain" about?
who knows?
Warren Beatty
Cat Stevens
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

While Carly Simon won't reveal who the song's about, lots of us can see our own ex in the lyrics.

Who got a smash hit with "I Heard It Through The Grapevine?"
Aretha Franklin
Marvin Gaye
Otis Redding
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Gladys Knight and the Pips also released it as a single, but it was Gaye's version that launched the song into pop culture.

When did Alanis Morissette's "You Oughta Know" come out?
1992
1995
1998
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

The mid-90s song became an anthem for jilted lovers everywhere.

Advertisement

Let's match the lyrics to the breakup song: "Loving you/Isn't the right thing to do/How can I ever change things/That I feel."
"Maggie May"
"Cathy's Clown"
"Go Your Own Way"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Fleetwood Mac had a lot of collective experience with breakups.

Who sang the plaintive "I'm Sorry," released in 1960?
Peggy Lee
Brenda Lee
Doris Day
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Brenda Lee was only 15 at the time, so she probably didn't have much to be sorry for.

"I should've changed that stupid lock/I should've made you leave your key/If I had known for just one second/You'd be back to bother me"
"Respect"
"I Am Woman"
"I Will Survive"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Gloria Gaynor may have been broken up with, but she was not about to go back to that dirtbag.

Advertisement

Who sang "You've Lost That Lovin' Feelin'?"
The Everly Brothers
The Righteous Brothers
Prince
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

It's gone. Gone. Gone.

What bouncy breakup song's lyrics (and title) were cleaned up to edit out the original four-letter send-off?
"Forget You"
"Go to Heck"
"Sorry My Elbow"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Cee Lo Green had a pretty simple message for his girl and her new man.

"How can you stop the rain from falling down?\How can you stop that old sun from shining?/What makes the world go round?"
"You Send Me"
"Try A Little Tenderness"
"How Can You Mend a Broken Heart"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Al Green's hit has been the soundtrack for many a broken-hearted soul.

Advertisement

The Magnetic Fields took a different approach with their breakup song. What's the title?
"No, It's Fine, I Was Going to Leave Anyway"
"I'll Just Die Now"
"I Don't Want to Get Over You"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Although Stephen Merritt should clearly write songs based on those other titles, too.

What breakup classic is on Carole King's album "Tapestry?"
"Back To California"
"Some Kind of Wonderful"
"It's Too Late"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

You can't beat a saxophone solo on a breakup song.

Something tells me we'll be hearing from Beyonce again, but where does she instruct her ex he'll find all his possessions in "Irreplaceable?"
at Becky's house
in the dumpster
in a box to the left
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Everything you own is in that box, sir.

Advertisement

"I was alright for awhile/I could smile for awhile/But I saw you last night/You held my hand so tight."
"Bawling"
"Crying"
"Sobbing"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Roy Orbison makes it very clear he was crying. Crying. CRYING.

Who promises that although they may have not treated their girl right, she was "Always On My Mind?"
Willie Nelson
Johnny Cash
Garth Brooks
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Cold comfort, perhaps, to the girl who he might've "treated second best."

What R&B singer needs her ex-lover to "Un-Break" her heart?
Toni Braxton
Kelly Rowland
Michelle Williams
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Many a broken heart would like to be pieced together again by the person who broke it in the first place.

Advertisement

"I heard that you're settled down/That you found a girl and you're married now/I heard that your dreams came true/Guess she gave you things I didn't give to you."
"Rolling in the Deep"
"Someone Like You"
"Shake It Off"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Adele knows her breakups.

"There's a fire starting in my heart/Reaching a fever pitch, and it's bringing me out the dark/Finally, I can see you crystal clear."
"Skyfall"
"Hello"
"Rolling in the Deep"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Sometimes a breakup is a woman scorned, Adele will also have you know.

What's a lyric from Bonnie Raitt's classic breakup song "I Can't Make You Love Me?"
"Lay down with me/Tell me no lies/Just hold me close, don't patronize"
"Don't be a jerk/just leave me be/I love you/you don't love me"
"Give me a break/you take take take/I'll give what I get/so take my hate"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

But you're WELCOME for the lyric ideas, Miss Raitt.

Advertisement

"Wait, they don't love you like I love you."
"Since U Been Gone"
"Maps"
"Roar"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

The Yeah Yeah Yeahs hit single was a quiet departure from their usually avant garde indie punk rock.

Whitney Houston made "I Will Always Love You" a monster hit, but who first wrote and recorded the song?
Aretha Franklin
Dolly Parton
Cissy Houston
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Dolly Parton's country version is worth a listen.

Bob Dylan wrote and recorded "It Ain't Me Babe" but what couple added their own spin on the breakup song?
Beyoncé and Jay Z
Johnny Carter and June Cash
Taylor Swift and Harry Styles
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Although I think we'd all kill to hear Tay and Harry duet.

Advertisement

What powerful breakup ballad was actually recorded for a forgettable film of the same name?
"Sad Story"
"Against All Odds"
"Empty Space"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Take a look at me now, Phil Collins begs.

Who sings the original version of the country standard "I Fall to Pieces?"
Patsy Cline
Martina McBride
Tammy Wynette
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Patsy is seriously not interested in being friends, buddy.

"You keep saying, you got something for me/Something you call love but confess/You've been messin' where you shouldn't have been messin'/And now someone else is getting all your best."
"Walking After Midnight"
"You've Got to Hide Your Love Away"
"These Boots Are Made for Walkin'"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Let's not forget that Nancy Sinatra doesn't stand for "lyin' when you oughta be truthin'."

Advertisement

What devastated crooner would "Rather Go Blind" than see her lover walk away?
Sarah Vaughan
Nina Simone
Etta James
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

When Etta says she was JUST sitting there thinking of his kiss, you can't help but curse the jerk.

Who wrote the Beatles' "For No One?"
Paul McCartney
John Lennon
George Harrison
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

You stay home; she goes out. Sigh.

"Back beat, the word is on the street/that the fire in your heart is out/I'm sure you've heard it all before/but you never really had a doubt."
"New Partner"
"La Cienega Just Smiled"
"Wonderwall"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Who hasn't wanted to yell at someone, "I don't believe that anybody feels the way I do about you now?"

Advertisement

"But he's driving and striving and hugging the turns/And thinking of someone for whom he still burns."
"A Man of Constant Sorrow"
"Romeo and Juliet"
"The Distance"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

There's nothing like driving, guitars and Cake.

Who wrote the Sinead O'Connor hit "Nothing Compares 2 U?"
Sinead O'Connor
Prince
Elvis Costello
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Sinead made it a hit and helped a lot of folks cry through their breakup.

"He better call Becky with the good hair."
"Sorry"
"Thinking About You"
"Bootylicious"
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Beyonce says "Boy, bye."

Advertisement

You Got:
/30
H. Armstrong Roberts/ClassicStock/Getty